August 16th, 2007 - by Golgotha

Our Swedish friend Roger Johansson asks the question, “Are we designers or developers?

“On the about page of this site I used to call myself a “developer/designer/occasional writer”. It’s a bit confusing, and I still find it hard to know what to answer when someone asks me what I do for a living. Am I a Web designer? A Web developer? A Web programmer? All of them? Neither? It really is a difficult question to give a simple answer to.”Roger Johansson

Like Roger, I have struggled with this question. Then about two years ago I decided to just pick an answer and go with it; that way when the hair dresser asks me the question I don’t sit there and go “um…ah…er…developer” and they end up thinking I’m lying and I’m really a spy or something.

So my answer is: I’m a developer!

I decided to steal my answer from the home building industry. Someone who builds homes for a living will often choose to call them self by the generic term developer. They may be an architect or mason or a carpenter, but those are the more specific skills used on the job — they call themselves home developers.

They use architectural skills to ensure that the house is designed well; that it’s structurally sound. Then using masonry and carpentry skills they build the home.

This is the similar to building a website. You design the site using pencil, paper, Photoshop and your learned knowledge of what it takes to make a website “structurally sound” and then you develop the site using HTML, CSS, PHP and all the other tools that go into developing websites.

So in my mind we’re both developers — they develop homes and I develop websites.

What’s your take — designer, developer, programmer or other?

When someone asks what you do for a living, what’s your answer?

7 Responses to “Are we Designers or Developers? – My Answer is…”

1 cpradio

I am a Programmer with Design experience 😉 Primarily I use the term programmer, as I prefer doing backend work versus the frontend and it clearly states I prefer writing code than HTML/CSS. GUIs are nice, but the real work is on the server-side in my opinion.

Writing connections to talk to the mainframe, sql server, mysql, oracle, other sites, etc. That is my turn-on in an average day of work.

2 John

I cut my own hair so I never have anyone ask me what I do. 😉

3 ses5909

I am a developer all the way!

4 peter

I have a very strong opinion about this, so please forgive me, and understand that my experience is anecdotal and may not reflect your experience. I am a designer. I have two degrees in design, one in Graphic Design (Fine Art) and the other in Graphic Communication (Technical Design for Production Environments). Trust me, I feel you, just having to explain the difference between those is a headache enough in itself. I am also a self-taught hand-coding XHTML/CSS/PHP web developer. I did not learn these things in school because when I was in school the latter did not exist. I am now a professional web designer. So, what do I refer to myself as? A Designer without hesitation. This is because I have met many developers who come from programming backgrounds and like to fancy themselves designers just because they know how to use Photoshop and can skin a website. However, I feel that this really robs true designers of their deserved title. I spent years learning not only the software but also principles of design, visual communication, composition, color theory, history of design, etc. It really takes a certain type of eye, discipline, and a high degree of anality to be a (good) designer. This goes both ways of course, because I never regard myself as a developer for respect of my colleagues who are far more adept and have a much deeper understanding of programming languages, scripting, databases, and AJAX. Don’t get me wrong, I also know a few developers who are fantastic designers, some people are just born with it (read: attention to detail), but I just think that there are enough people out there who give themselves a little too much credit and I think as long as a little respect is paid where due then we will all appreciate each others’ skills and trade to the fullest. Thanks for the topic, great article!

5 Golgotha

@Peter: I hear you and fully agree. Some developers are not designers, no matter what they say and some designers are not developers . But, that’s another article. Great comment!

6 Thejesh GN

Thanks for writing this. I use coder most of the time. Coding is what I like to do. Being coder doesn’t mean I don’t design.Probably Developer is one word which combines both of these. I will try to use “Developer” next time.

7 Andrew Pryde

I would consider myself to be a developer becuase I came from a programing background but not most of the work I end up doing is design work as small businesses rarely need a fully functional web application designed they either don’t use one or just instruct me to implement an open source one. I think this is a shame becuase it is getting things to work and knowing why they work that interests me. Having said this I am a realist and realise that I do what I do and that its not going to change so I have grown to enjoy the design aspect as well 🙂

Andrew

mulberry sale spyder womens jacket cheap new balance 574 mulberry outlet cheap new balance 574 arcteryx outlet mulberry sale spyder womens jacket mulberry sale spyder womens jacket mulberry outlet mulberry outlet new balance 574

Popular Articles

Top 10 Commentators


Subscribe to this feed! Subscribe by Email!

Random Bits Podcast

You need to download the Flash player from Adobe

Blogs Worth Reading